Order by 2 PM for Next Day Pick-Up! BIG DISCOUNTS with BUNDLE & SAVE Up To 20% OFF!

Our Cheesecake is So Good, It's Legendary

Our New York Cheesecake is dense, rich, sumptuous, creamy, indulgent, heavenly and out of this world.

Our Cheesecake has been taste tested and proven to be more decadent and superior to any other product. Made to Order in 33 flavors with various sizes, crusts and toppings.

Baked Fresh Daily

All Cheesecakes are Made to Order Fresh with No Preservatives. Our Cheesecakes are NOT brought in, we Bake them Fresh on Premises!

Locally sourced Farm Fresh Whole Milk, 40% Extra Heavy Cream; Free from antibiotics and artificial growth hormones (rBGH). All Eggs are Certified Cage and Antibiotic Free. All Natural & Nothing Else!

All Products are Kosher K כָּשֵׁר Dairy!

Most Popular Whole Cheesecakes

Baked Fresh and Ready in 24 Hours!
  • New York Deli Style Cheesecake
    New York Deli Style Cheesecake
    New York Deli Style Cheesecake

    New York Deli Style Cheesecake

    Regular price $29.95+
  • Oreo Cheesecake
    Oreo Cheesecake
    Oreo Cheesecake

    Oreo Cheesecake

    Regular price $29.95+
  • Death By Chocolate Cheesecake
    Death By Chocolate Cheesecake
    Death By Chocolate Cheesecake

    Death By Chocolate Cheesecake

    Regular price $29.95+
  • Berry-Berrie Strawberry Cheesecake
    Berry-Berrie Strawberry Cheesecake
    Berry-Berrie Strawberry Cheesecake

    Berry-Berrie Strawberry Cheesecake

    Regular price $29.95+
  • Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Cheesecake
    Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Cheesecake
    Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Cheesecake

    Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Cheesecake

    Regular price $29.95+
  • Lemon Delight Cheesecake
    Lemon Delight Cheesecake
    Lemon Delight Cheesecake

    Lemon Delight Cheesecake

    Regular price $29.95+
  • Vanilla Latte Cheesecake
    Vanilla Latte Cheesecake
    Vanilla Latte Cheesecake

    Vanilla Latte Cheesecake

    Regular price $34.95+
  • Cinnamon Fusion Cheesecake
    Cinnamon Fusion Cheesecake
    Cinnamon Fusion Cheesecake

    Cinnamon Fusion Cheesecake

    Regular price $34.95+
  • S'Mores Please Cheesecake
    S'Mores Please Cheesecake
    S'Mores Please Cheesecake

    S'Mores Please Cheesecake

    Regular price $34.95+
  • Nana Banana Cheesecake
    Nana Banana Cheesecake
    Nana Banana Cheesecake

    Nana Banana Cheesecake

    Regular price $29.95+
  • Fun-Fetti Rainbow Birthday Cheesecake
    Fun-Fetti Rainbow Birthday Cheesecake
    Fun-Fetti Rainbow Birthday Cheesecake

    Fun-Fetti Rainbow Birthday Cheesecake

    Regular price $34.95+
  • Carrot Cake Truffle Cream Cheesecake
    Carrot Cake Truffle Cream Cheesecake
    Carrot Cake Truffle Cream Cheesecake

    Carrot Cake Truffle Cream Cheesecake

    Regular price $34.95+
  • Chocolate Blackout Raspberry Cheesecake
    Chocolate Blackout Raspberry Cheesecake
    Chocolate Blackout Raspberry Cheesecake

    Chocolate Blackout Raspberry Cheesecake

    Regular price $34.95+
  • Gluten Free - New York Deli Style Cheesecake
    Gluten Free - New York Deli Style Cheesecake
    Gluten Free - New York Deli Style Cheesecake

    Gluten Free - New York Deli Style Cheesecake

    Regular price $39.95+
  • THE SAMPLER!  4 Inch Personal Cheesecake (4 Pack)
    THE SAMPLER!  4 Inch Personal Cheesecake (4 Pack)
    THE SAMPLER! 4 Inch Personal Cheesecake (4 Pack)

    THE SAMPLER! 4 Inch Personal Cheesecake (4 Pack)

    Regular price $49.95
  • Bitty Bites (24 Pack) - GLUTEN FREE
    Bitty Bites (24 Pack) - GLUTEN FREE
    Bitty Bites (24 Pack) - GLUTEN FREE

    Bitty Bites (24 Pack) - GLUTEN FREE

    Regular price $29.95
  • Caramel Pretzel Cheesecake
    Caramel Pretzel Cheesecake
    Caramel Pretzel Cheesecake

    Caramel Pretzel Cheesecake

    Regular price $34.95+
  • Java B'Nana Cheesecake
    Java B'Nana Cheesecake
    Java B'Nana Cheesecake

    Java B'Nana Cheesecake

    Regular price $34.95+

Fresh & All Natural

  • NO Artificial Colors or Flavors

  • NO Guar Gum, Carrageenan, Xanthan Gum

  • NO Chemical Additives or Preservatives

  • NO Animal Gelatin or Rennet

  • Organic Fresh Fruit-Natural Ingredients.

  • ServSafe™ Inspected and Licensed

  • Nut Free Facility

  • Kosher Dairy

You Will Love Our Cheesecakes!

What makes us Better?

  • Finest Organic Ingredients

    Madagascar Vanilla; Ceylon Cinnamon; Belgium Dark Chocolate; Fresh Fruit; Freshly Baked Cookies for our Crusts and Brownies.

    1
  • Artisan Cream Cheese

    Cream Cheese made with Farm Fresh Whole Milk, 40% Extra Heavy Cream, ProBiotics, St. Johns Bread and Salt.

    2
  • No Artificial Additives

    No Chemical Preservatives or Additives, No Animal Gelatin or Rennet, No Artificial Colors or Flavors, No Skim Milk Cheese Fillers. Nut Free!

    3

THE SAMPLER 4 Pack! Personal Cheesecake

MIX & MATCH FLAVORS:

Can't Decide on a flavor? Create your own Sample Pack.  Yes, you can mix and match flavors for samples.  Our Sample Pack is not pre-determined, this is Totally Custom Made just for You! Perfect for wedding tastings gifts and more.  For each 4-Pack; you can have one of each flavor, or all the same, all sampler selections include our standard toppings.

One 4 Inch New York Pudgie has the same amount of cheesecake that you would get in a Massive slice from the Carnegie Deli!

Our New York Pudgies are 3/4 pounds of Cheesecake you can hold with one hand, Baked in an 4 inch diameter pan, 2 inches thick.  A Pudgie is 50% more cheesecake per pound than a standard restaurant slice. Sold in 4 Flavor Mix'n Match packs.

What Customer's are Saying!

  • ★★★★★

    “Seriously, the best cheesecake I've ever had! I ordered the cinnamon roll cheesecake and it was delivered to my door in Miami looking amazing. It tasted even better. I will be ordering more for upcoming events and family gatherings. Can't recommend this enough!!!”

    Aaron M. - Key Biscayne, FL
  • ★★★★★

    “The Cheesecake Bites are to die for! First bite you just close your eyes and melt...”

    Sue B. – Pittsburgh, PA
  • ★★★★★

    “Excellent customer service, reasonably priced products, on-time delivery AND the best darn cheesecake you'll ever have! I ordered the lemon and it was soooo good! I highly recommend this company!”

    Karen W. - Sacramento, CA
  • ★★★★★

    “Wow! Received my order 2 days ago via FedEx. The taste and the quality was beyond all expectations. I am addicted! Great job NY Cheesecake!”

    Leo G. - Moneta, VA
  • ★★★★★

    “it's really fabulous and we have great confidence that there wouldn't be a person on the planet that wouldn't love it!”

    Debbie T. - Austin, TX
  • ★★★★★

    “Ridiculously Awesome. I would put this Cheesecake up against any other in the world. Not in the State, not in the City, in the World.”

    Joe T. - Pittsburgh, PA
  • ★★★★★

    “OMG, this cheesecake is for real! This was served at a party and everyone was like, whaaat! Your recipe is Legit!!”

    Clarence J. - Brooklyn, NY
  • ★★★★★

    “Ordered the Death By Chocolate and now I am in Heaven. WOW!”

    Karen S. - Columbus, OH
  • ★★★★★

    “Online Ordering was easy and product came fast! Thank you for the Best Cheesecake I have ever tasted! Goes great with Texas BBQ.”

    Jason S. - Austin, TX
  • ★★★★★

    “All I can say is WOW! The cheesecake is absolutely phenomenal, the best I ever tasted.”

    George P. - Pittsburgh, PA
  • ★★★★★

    “This cheesecake is out of this world delicious. I've had the lemon and let me tell you it is very lemony. Just the way I like it. I can't wait to try more flavors.”

    H. B. - Pittsburgh, PA
  • ★★★★★

    “Outrageously Scrumptious, Creamy and Done to PERFECTION! Down right yummy!

    Living in Florida, I was afraid our Cheesecake was going to melt, prior to getting to us. NOT THE CASE! Packaging was still frozen when it got here.

    Thank you New York Cheesecake Company for the best dessert we've had in a very long time!”

    Susan Z, - Jacksonville, FL
  • ★★★★★

    “We purchased 6 dozen Bitty Bites in 3 different flavors to offer at my nephew's wedding. They were delicious and everyone seemed to like them. Easy to transport and plate, too. I would buy them again! Enjoy!”

    Pauline D. - Bethel Park, PA
  • ★★★★★

    “Awesome cheesecake!  I purchased it for my employees and everyone loved it.  I am planning on purchasing their Red, white and blue cheesecake for the 4th of July.
    It will be the hit of the party.”

    Deanne O. - Bridgeville, PA
  • ★★★★★

    “I love it that the Berry-Berrie cheesecake that I purchased has fresh strawberries and raspberries blended right into the cheesecake itself. Most companies only place the fruit on the top. The chocolate cookie crust and chocolate ganache top layer are a perfect complement to the flavor of the berries. I tried to have only one piece but had to have a second piece right away. The cheesecake is so good! It is awesome that these are made-from-scratch with real food ingredients and no nasty food additives. Looking forward to trying some of the other cheesecakes from this company.”

    Lynn M. - Beaver, PA

Unique and Special Whole Cheesecakes

Baked Fresh and Ready in 24 Hours!
  • Cinnamon Fusion Cheesecake
    Cinnamon Fusion Cheesecake
    Cinnamon Fusion Cheesecake

    Cinnamon Fusion Cheesecake

    Regular price $34.95+
  • S'Mores Please Cheesecake
    S'Mores Please Cheesecake
    S'Mores Please Cheesecake

    S'Mores Please Cheesecake

    Regular price $34.95+
  • Caramel Apple Crumb Cheesecake
    Caramel Apple Crumb Cheesecake
    Caramel Apple Crumb Cheesecake

    Caramel Apple Crumb Cheesecake

    Regular price $34.95+
  • Carrot Cake Truffle Cream Cheesecake
    Carrot Cake Truffle Cream Cheesecake
    Carrot Cake Truffle Cream Cheesecake

    Carrot Cake Truffle Cream Cheesecake

    Regular price $34.95+
  • Ultimate Tuxedo Cheesecake
    Ultimate Tuxedo Cheesecake
    Ultimate Tuxedo Cheesecake

    Ultimate Tuxedo Cheesecake

    Regular price $36.95+
  • Vanilla Latte Cheesecake
    Vanilla Latte Cheesecake
    Vanilla Latte Cheesecake

    Vanilla Latte Cheesecake

    Regular price $34.95+
  • Mocha Cappuccino Supreme Cheesecake
    Mocha Cappuccino Supreme Cheesecake
    Mocha Cappuccino Supreme Cheesecake

    Mocha Cappuccino Supreme Cheesecake

    Regular price $44.95+
  • Red Velvet Romance Cheesecake
    Red Velvet Romance Cheesecake
    Red Velvet Romance Cheesecake

    Red Velvet Romance Cheesecake

    Regular price $49.95+
  • Cool Peppermint Cheesecake
    Cool Peppermint Cheesecake
    Cool Peppermint Cheesecake

    Cool Peppermint Cheesecake

    Regular price $29.95+
  • Banana Split Cheesecake
    Banana Split Cheesecake
    Banana Split Cheesecake

    Banana Split Cheesecake

    Regular price $44.95+
  • Berry-Berrie Patriotic Cheesecake
    Berry-Berrie Patriotic Cheesecake
    Berry-Berrie Patriotic Cheesecake

    Berry-Berrie Patriotic Cheesecake

    Regular price $44.95+
  • Orange Creamsicle Cheesecake
    Orange Creamsicle Cheesecake
    Orange Creamsicle Cheesecake

    Orange Creamsicle Cheesecake

    Regular price $39.95+
  • Bitty Bites (24 Pack) - GLUTEN FREE
    Bitty Bites (24 Pack) - GLUTEN FREE
    Bitty Bites (24 Pack) - GLUTEN FREE

    Bitty Bites (24 Pack) - GLUTEN FREE

    Regular price $29.95
  • THE SAMPLER!  4 Inch Personal Cheesecake (4 Pack)
    THE SAMPLER!  4 Inch Personal Cheesecake (4 Pack)
    THE SAMPLER! 4 Inch Personal Cheesecake (4 Pack)

    THE SAMPLER! 4 Inch Personal Cheesecake (4 Pack)

    Regular price $49.95
  • Shortbread Millionaire Cheesecake
    Shortbread Millionaire Cheesecake
    Shortbread Millionaire Cheesecake

    Shortbread Millionaire Cheesecake

    Regular price $44.95+
  • Fun-Fetti Rainbow Birthday Cheesecake
    Fun-Fetti Rainbow Birthday Cheesecake
    Fun-Fetti Rainbow Birthday Cheesecake

    Fun-Fetti Rainbow Birthday Cheesecake

    Regular price $34.95+
  • Tiramisu Mocha Ripple Cheesecake
    Tiramisu Mocha Ripple Cheesecake
    Tiramisu Mocha Ripple Cheesecake

    Tiramisu Mocha Ripple Cheesecake

    Regular price $34.95+
  • Java B'Nana Cheesecake
    Java B'Nana Cheesecake
    Java B'Nana Cheesecake

    Java B'Nana Cheesecake

    Regular price $34.95+

Blog posts

  • New Bakery Test Kitchen

    New Bakery Test Kitchen

  • Cream Cheese

    Cream Cheese

  • Cheesecakes for Fundraising

    Cheesecakes for Fundraising

  • Taste Tested

    Taste Tested

Sign up to our newsletter

Receive special offers and first look at new products.