Order by 2 PM for Next Day Pick-Up! BIG DISCOUNTS with BUNDLE & SAVE Up To 15% OFF!

Holiday Favorites

  • New York Deli Style Cheesecake

    New York Deli Style Cheesecake

    $29.95+
  • Berry-Berrie Strawberry Cheesecake

    Berry-Berrie Strawberry Cheesecake

    $29.95+
  • Death By Chocolate Cheesecake

    Death By Chocolate Cheesecake

    $37.95+
  • Carrot Cake Truffle Cream Cheesecake

    Carrot Cake Truffle Cream Cheesecake

    $34.95+
  • Nana Banana Cheesecake

    Nana Banana Cheesecake

    $29.95+
  • Lemon Delight Cheesecake

    Lemon Delight Cheesecake

    $29.95+
  • Key Lime Cheesecake

    Key Lime Cheesecake

    $29.95+
  • Red Velvet Romance Cheesecake

    Red Velvet Romance Cheesecake

    $49.95+
  • Berry-Berrie Patriotic Cheesecake

    Berry-Berrie Patriotic Cheesecake

    $44.95+
  • Bailey's Irish Cream Cheesecake

    Bailey's Irish Cream Cheesecake

    $49.95+
  • Chocolate Blackout Raspberry Cheesecake

    Chocolate Blackout Raspberry Cheesecake

    $34.95+
  • Fun-Fetti Rainbow Birthday Cheesecake

    Fun-Fetti Rainbow Birthday Cheesecake

    $34.95+
  • Tiramisu Mocha Ripple Cheesecake

    Tiramisu Mocha Ripple Cheesecake

    $44.95+
  • Caramel Pretzel Cheesecake

    Caramel Pretzel Cheesecake

    $34.95+
  • Java B'Nana Cheesecake

    Java B'Nana Cheesecake

    $34.95+
  • Mango Tropical Twist Cheesecake

    Mango Tropical Twist Cheesecake

    $34.95+
  • Peach Cobbler Cheesecake

    Peach Cobbler Cheesecake

    $34.95+
  • StrawBerry-Berrie Dump Cake Cheesecake

    StrawBerry-Berrie Dump Cake Cheesecake

    $44.95+
  • Cookies & Cream Brownie Fantasy Cheesecake made with OREO® Cookies

    Cookies & Cream Brownie Fantasy Cheesecake made with OREO® Cookies

    $39.95+
  • Biscoff Cookie Butter Cheesecake

    Biscoff Cookie Butter Cheesecake

    $39.95+
  • Banoffee (Banana & Caramel) Cheesecake

    Banoffee (Banana & Caramel) Cheesecake

    $34.95+
  • Berrie-B'Nana Cheesecake

    Berrie-B'Nana Cheesecake

    $34.95+

BBB Accredited Business with A+ Rating

The New York Cheesecake Company BBB Business Review

Nominated for the 2025 BBB Torch Awards for Ethics!
Licensed and Inspected by the Allegheny County Health Department
Licensed and Inspected by the The Pennsylvania Department of Agriculture
Trained and Certified ServSafe® for proper Food Handling and Safety by the National Restaurant Association and Certified as a Nut-Free Facility!
We are accredited by ANSI-ANAB-CFP (American National Standards Institute, the National Accreditation Board & the Conference for Food Protection)