Order by 2 PM for Next Day Pick-Up! BIG DISCOUNTS with BUNDLE & SAVE Up To 20% OFF!

  • THE SAMPLER!  4 Inch Personal Cheesecake (4 Pack)
  • THE SAMPLER!  4 Inch Personal Cheesecake (4 Pack)

THE SAMPLER! 4 Inch Personal Cheesecake (4 Pack)

New York Pudgie's "The Personal Sized Cheesecake"  "Selfishly 1 or nicely 2", perfect to share for date night or when you want a selection of flavors to try!


Can't Decide on a flavor? Create your own sample pack.  Yes, you can mix and match flavors for samples.  Perfect for wedding tastings.  For each 4-Pack; you can have one of each flavor, all sampler selections include our standard toppings:

At checkout in Customer Notes tell us the flavors you want.

Each Pudgie has the same amount of cheesecake that you would get in a Massive slice from the Carnegie Deli!

Yes, each Pudgie is 3/4 pounds of Cheesecake you can hold with one hand, Baked in an 4 inch diameter pan, 2 inch thickness.  A Pudgie is 50% more cheesecake per pound than a standard restaurant slice. Sold in 4 pack.

All Products are Kosher K כָּשֵׁר Dairy!
Regular price
BUNDLE & SAVE with Quantity Discounts: Buy 2 Save 5%; 3 Save 10%; 4 Save 15%; Buy 5 or more Save 20%! Yes, You can Mix & Match Different Flavors and Sizes!
Added to Cart! View cart or continue shopping.
FLAT RATE SHIPPING $9.98 for the first item in your cart; want more, ADD $5.00 for each extra item up to 5 Items per Order! UPS or FedEx 2-Day Cold Chain Delivery anywhere in the Contiguous United States. Need more than 5? Please call 📞 or email for Bulk Rate $$$ Pricing.

Customer Reviews

Based on 6 reviews
Richard Gradisek
We sent to Hawaii

The Akeo family 😋😋😋
Thank you

Candace Polk

These cakes are clearly made with love…

Excellent cheesecakes!

The process was easy and organized. I will recommend this company to friends!

Great cheesecake!

We had the pudgies sampler pack with four different types: Death by Chocolate, Vanilla Latte, Berry and Plain.
They were all fantastic! I truly could not decide which was my favorite.
Will definitely be ordering again and looking forward to trying more flavors!
If you are looking for great cheesecake, give it a try, you won’t be sorry!!


We are return customers.
We like trying new flavors and of course return for our favorites🥰