Order by 2 PM for FREE Next Day Local Pick-Up! BIG DISCOUNTS with BUNDLE & SAVE Up To 15% OFF! Need Local Delivery or Nationwide Shipping, Save with multi-item discounts!

Our Most Popular Cheesecakes

Custom made cheesecakes ready for Pick-Up in 24 hours!  Choose your flavor, size, crust and toppings!
  • Banoffee (Banana & Caramel) Cheesecake

    Banoffee (Banana & Caramel) Cheesecake

    $34.95+
  • Café Vanilla Latte Cheesecake

    Café Vanilla Latte Cheesecake

    $34.95+
  • Mocha Cappuccino Supreme Cheesecake

    Mocha Cappuccino Supreme Cheesecake

    $44.95+
  • Red Velvet Romance Cheesecake

    Red Velvet Romance Cheesecake

    $49.95+
  • Carrot Cake Cheesecake

    Carrot Cake Cheesecake

    $39.95+
  • Cool Peppermint Cheesecake

    Cool Peppermint Cheesecake

    $34.95+
  • Berrie-B'Nana Cheesecake

    Berrie-B'Nana Cheesecake

    $34.95+
  • Fudgey Monkey Cheesecake

    Fudgey Monkey Cheesecake

    $39.95+
  • Fudgee Wudgee Cheesecake

    Fudgee Wudgee Cheesecake

    $39.95+
  • Lemon Raspberry Swirl Cheesecake

    Lemon Raspberry Swirl Cheesecake

    $39.95+
  • Snicker Doodle Cheesecake

    Snicker Doodle Cheesecake

    $39.95+
  • Bailey's Irish Cream Cheesecake

    Bailey's Irish Cream Cheesecake

    $49.95+
  • Banana Split Cheesecake

    Banana Split Cheesecake

    $44.95+
  • S'Mores Oreo

    S'Mores Oreo

    $34.95+
  • S'Mores Chocolate Fudge

    S'Mores Chocolate Fudge

    $34.95+
  • French Toast Latte Cheesecake

    French Toast Latte Cheesecake

    $39.95+
  • Chocolate Cake Fudge Torte Cheesecake

    Chocolate Cake Fudge Torte Cheesecake

    $49.95+
  • Coffee Cake Streusel Cheesecake

    Coffee Cake Streusel Cheesecake

    $39.95+
  • Brownie Raspberry Bliss Cheesecake

    Brownie Raspberry Bliss Cheesecake

    $39.95+
  • Swirl Around the World Cheesecake - 12 Flavors

    Swirl Around the World Cheesecake - 12 Flavors

    $39.95+

BBB Accredited Business with A+ Rating

The New York Cheesecake Company BBB Business Review

Nominated for the 2025 BBB Torch Awards for Ethics!
Licensed and Inspected by the Allegheny County Health Department
Licensed and Inspected by the The Pennsylvania Department of Agriculture
Trained and Certified ServSafe® for proper Food Handling and Safety by the National Restaurant Association and Certified as a Nut-Free Facility!
We are accredited by ANSI-ANAB-CFP (American National Standards Institute, the National Accreditation Board & the Conference for Food Protection)