Fresh Baked Cheesecakes Made to Order in 24 to 48 Hours

  • Pudgies - The 4 Inch Personal Cheesecake (4 Pack); Great for Samples!
  • Pudgies - The 4 Inch Personal Cheesecake (4 Pack); Great for Samples!
  • Pudgies - The 4 Inch Personal Cheesecake (4 Pack); Great for Samples!
  • Pudgies - The 4 Inch Personal Cheesecake (4 Pack); Great for Samples!

Pudgies - The 4 Inch Personal Cheesecake (4 Pack); Great for Samples!

New York Pudgie's "The Personal Sized Cheesecake"  "Selfishly 1 or nicely 2", perfect to share for date night; 3/4 pounds of Cheesecake you can hold with one hand, Baked in an 4 inch diameter pan, 2 inch thickness.  Single Flavor Only.  A Pudgie is 50% more cheesecake per pound than a standard restaurant slice. Sold in 4 pack.

MIX & MATCH FLAVORS:

Can't Decide on a flavor? Create your own sample pack.  Yes, you can mix and match flavors for samples.  For each 4-Pack; you can have one of each flavor! When you order just pick one flavor, then at checkout in customer notes tell us the other flavors you want.  Perfect for event tastings.

Choice of Plain, Peppermint, Death By Chocolate, Oreo, Berry-Berrie, Lemon, S'mores, Pumpkin and Nana Banana flavored cheesecake pudgies.

All Products are Kosher K כָּשֵׁר Dairy!
Regular price
BUNDLE & SAVE with Quantity Discounts: Buy 2 Save 5%; 3 Save 10%; 4 Save 15%; Buy 5 or more Save 20%! Yes, You can Mix & Match Different Flavors and Sizes!
FLAT RATE SHIPPING $9.98 for the first item in your cart; want more, ADD $5.00 for each extra item up to 5 Items per Order! UPS or FedEx 2-Day Cold Chain Delivery anywhere in the Contiguous United States. Need more than 5? Please call 📞 or email for Bulk Rate $$$ Pricing.

Customer Reviews

Based on 4 reviews
100%
(4)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
N
NANCY KOSIOR
Excellent cheesecakes!

The process was easy and organized. I will recommend this company to friends!

D
DON
Great cheesecake!

We had the pudgies sampler pack with four different types: Death by Chocolate, Vanilla Latte, Berry and Plain.
They were all fantastic! I truly could not decide which was my favorite.
Will definitely be ordering again and looking forward to trying more flavors!
If you are looking for great cheesecake, give it a try, you won’t be sorry!!

J
Jodi
Yum

We are return customers.
We like trying new flavors and of course return for our favorites🥰

A
Arthur Tiller
Excellent!

This is some of the best cheesecake I've ever eaten! I ordered a cheesecake sampler and shared it with friends. Everyone raved. Every one was DELICIOUS!